Brian Duker stands among Jets players at practice, holding a pen and play sheet.

Brian Duker’s Jets Defense Faces McDaniel’s Motion Test

November 20, 2026
Brian Duker stands among Jets players at practice, holding a pen and play sheet.

Brian Duker’s Jets Defense Faces McDaniel’s Motion Test

November 20, 2026
Jets Analysis

Watch: Pat's Jets Trade-Up Case for Drew Mestemaker

Pat’s Jets trade-up case in his November 18, 2026 discussion starts with a condition: if the Jets believe Drew Mestemaker is the quarterback who can change their future, he supports paying to get him. If their evaluation favors CJ Carr and they can stay put to select him, keeping that draft flexibility could be the better choice. Pat likes the aggressive route, but the quarterback evaluation has to come first.

Why Pat would trade up for Mestemaker

The appeal is getting the preferred quarterback without abandoning the rest of the roster. Jordan Reid’s ESPN mock draft imagines the Jets trading premium draft capital to the Chargers for the opportunity to select Mestemaker, while retaining an opportunity to add Leonard Moore. Moore is a Notre Dame cornerback, giving that scenario a defensive addition alongside the investment at quarterback.

For Pat, that combination makes the proposal worth considering. The attraction isn’t moving up for its own sake. It’s using draft capital to secure a player the Jets believe can change the offense, with room left to keep building. Holding onto picks has value, but so does turning them into access to the quarterback they actually want. His enthusiasm rests on that distinction.

The evaluation has to justify the price

Pat raises Carr as the alternative that could change the decision. If the Jets evaluate Carr more highly and expect him to be available where they select, they may be better off staying there. That is a meaningful condition, because it makes the trade a means of acquiring the preferred player rather than the goal of the offseason.

The cost matters differently depending on that judgment. Spending capital to reach a quarterback the Jets prefer is a different proposition from spending it when their preferred option could come to them. Pat’s support for Mestemaker does not erase the Carr possibility; it leaves the scouting evaluation responsible for deciding which path makes sense.

The broader quarterback conversation also includes Pat’s November 16 remaining-season evaluation argument and the separate analysis of Cade Klubnik’s debut decisions. Here, the choice is how to approach the next rookie investment.

The rookie needs a development plan

Pat wants offensive-minded coaching and a chance for the rookie to learn behind Geno Smith. The ambition to acquire a quarterback comes with patience about putting him on the field. In Pat’s preferred approach, landing the prospect is the beginning of the work, not a reason to expect an instant cure.

He also likes the offensive pieces a young quarterback could work with. Garrett Wilson, Armand Membou and Kenyon Sadiq are among the players behind that optimism; the Jets’ roster lists them at wide receiver, offensive tackle and tight end, respectively. Pat sees a foundation worth pairing with a rookie and offensive coaching.

His November 12 discussion of Geno as a veteran bridge offers earlier context for that preference. The next-season development question is how to give a young quarterback useful preparation, rather than making the acquisition price dictate when he must play.

Watch the November 18 discussion

Watch Pat’s full November 18 discussion for his argument about pursuing Mestemaker, considering Carr and building around a rookie. His preferred outcome leaves room for either paying to reach the right prospect or waiting when the evaluation supports it. Would you spend the capital to secure your preferred quarterback, or keep the flexibility if your evaluation points toward a player who could fall to you?